An analysis by the Complaints Portal reveals a significant increase in consumer complaints directed at debt collection companies. Between January 1st and June 30th of this year, Portuguese citizens filed 283 complaints.
The study indicates that there are outraged consumers who allege persecution by asset management entities for the payment of non-existent or time-barred debts. The analyzed data points to Intrum, with 65,7%, and Whitestar Asset Solutions, with 21,2%, as the most complained-about companies.
expressive growth
Analysis by the Portal da Queixa team has identified a significant increase in complaints over the last few years. Compared to the same period in 2018, the total number of complaints was 234, and in 2019, the total number of complaints filed was 276, while in the first half of 2020, 283 have already been recorded.
Among the main reasons that generated complaints on Portugal's largest consumer social network are non-existent debt (34,3%), time-barred debt (23,7%) and threats (17%).
While Intrum leads in complaints for alleged debt collection related to telecommunications and energy suppliers—that is, amounts owed for non-payment of essential services—Whitestar Asset Solutions has seen its share of complaints increase exponentially in the last three months for alleged debt collection related to overdue loans from banking institutions.
The data analysis reflects that both companies are the target of indignation and dissatisfaction from Portuguese consumers, who accuse them of charging amounts they do not recognize as owed, either because they are no longer collectible due to prescription, or because there is no proof of their existence.
According to the complaints filed by the Portal da Queixa (Complaints Portal), many of the alleged debts collected by Whitestar Asset Solutions refer to outstanding amounts from loans with banking and financial institutions, which are now being brought to light with the justification that they were sold by the creditors to asset management funds and, therefore, are owed even if to a different entity. However, some consumers claim that the company does not provide the burden of proof to support the veracity of the debt, thus demanding payment for something it does not legitimize.
Stigma related to debt.
In light of the complaints reported on the platform, if the consumer does not accept the validity of the debt, their name will be placed on the Bank of Portugal's blacklist, without the possibility of defending themselves, given that most of the debts relate to periods more than 10 years old, making it difficult to have proof to support their settlement. " It seems that most consumers contacted by debt collection companies will be forced to make the payment against their will, in order to avoid having their name kept on the Bank of Portugal's blacklist ," indicates the Complaint Portal.
The analysis of complaint resolution also reflected the positive aspects of other brands such as Indebt, which has a high satisfaction rate (83,6%) and a high resolution rate (70%). In contrast, the Intrum brand has only 5% of cases resolved, as does Whitestar, which also registers a very low resolution rate of 7%.
" Unfortunately, we very frequently receive reports from consumers complaining about being harassed by asset management companies for the payment of debts they allegedly do not recognize or that were settled a long time ago, and they now have no way to prove this. Since the burden of proof lies with the creditor – when requested – consumer reports indicate that these alleged debts should no longer be subject to collection, as they are either settled or time-barred, which calls into question the legitimacy of these entities in carrying out this behavior. Consequently, I emphasize that it is up to consumers to demand proof of debt before proceeding with payment, and to the regulator (Bank of Portugal) to ensure that there are no abuses or violations of their rights. Regrettably, we must agree that in our society there is still a huge stigma related to non-performing loans, often as a consequence of crises like the one we are currently experiencing, which is used as a psychological weapon to force consumers to pay allegedly undue amounts, out of shame." "Seeing their name on the Bank of Portugal's list. As a society, we must be more inclusive in creating new solutions that allow consumers to return to the economy, overcoming the stigmas resulting from the difficulties of today's times ," argues Pedro Lourenço, CEO of Portal da Queixa.








